Crates Health

Table of Contents

• The Modern Supplement Reality Check
• Why Supplementation Matters More Than Ever
• The Broken Food System Problem
• Navigating the Supplement Wild West
• The HSA/FSA Game Changer
• How to Use Your HSA/FSA for Supplements
• Medical Conditions and Supplement Support
• Building Your HSA-Eligible Stack
• The Bottom Line

The Modern Supplement Reality Check

Your parents probably think supplements are expensive pee. They’re not entirely wrong, but they’re not right either. The supplement industry is worth $177 billion globally, and it’s not because we’re all delusional. It’s because our food system is fundamentally different than it was 50 years ago, our lifestyles have dramatically shifted, and modern science has validated what traditional medicine has known for centuries: targeted supplementation can be a game-changer for health.

Here’s what’s actually happening: we’re the first generation that legitimately needs to think about supplementation as part of basic health maintenance. Not because we’re weak or paranoid, but because the math simply doesn’t work anymore when it comes to getting optimal nutrition from food alone.

Why Supplementation Matters More Than Ever

The data is actually shocking when you dig into it. A University of Texas study found that between 1950 and 1999, vegetables showed significant decreases in protein, calcium, phosphorus, iron, riboflavin, and vitamin C. We’re talking about:

• 43% decline in iron content in foods
• 12% decline in calcium
• 15% decline in vitamin A
• 38% decline in vitamin C

This isn’t some conspiracy theory. It’s published, peer-reviewed research showing that an orange today has 50% less vitamin C than an orange your grandparents ate. You’d literally need to eat twice as many oranges to get the same nutritional value. And who’s doing that?

Meanwhile, our need for nutrients has arguably increased. Chronic stress depletes B vitamins and magnesium. Blue light exposure from screens increases our need for lutein and zeaxanthin. Research from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey shows that:

• 95% of Americans don’t get enough vitamin D
• 90% don’t get enough vitamin E
• 70% are deficient in calcium
• 60% are deficient in magnesium

These aren’t fringe health optimizer stats. This is the average American walking around functionally deficient in multiple essential nutrients.

The Broken Food System Problem

“Just eat whole foods” isn’t the complete answer anymore. Modern agriculture has optimized for yield, shelf life, and appearance, not nutritional density.

Soil depletion is real and measurable. Industrial farming practices have stripped minerals from soil faster than they can be naturally replenished. A landmark study in the Journal of the American College of Nutrition compared nutrient data from 1950 and 1999 for 43 different vegetables and fruits, finding “reliable declines” in protein, calcium, phosphorus, iron, riboflavin (vitamin B2), and vitamin C.

Then there’s the time factor. That “fresh” produce in your grocery store? It was likely picked weeks ago, shipped thousands of miles, and has been slowly degrading nutritionally ever since. Research from Penn State shows that spinach loses 90% of its vitamin C within 24 hours of harvest when stored at room temperature.

Factor in modern lifestyle stressors that increase nutrient needs:

• Chronic stress burns through B vitamins
• Alcohol depletes thiamine, folate, and B12
• Birth control pills deplete folate, vitamins B2, B6, B12, C, and E
• Common medications like statins reduce CoQ10 levels
• PPIs (acid blockers) impair B12, iron, calcium, and magnesium absorption

The math simply doesn’t add up anymore. You’d need to eat an almost impossible amount of perfect, fresh, organic food to meet optimal nutrient levels. And even then, you’d probably fall short.

Navigating the Supplement Wild West

Here’s where things get tricky. The supplement industry is essentially the Wild West of health products. The FDA doesn’t pre-approve supplements for safety or efficacy. They only step in after problems are reported. This means the market is flooded with everything from pharmaceutical-grade nutrients to expensive sawdust.

The good news? There are legitimate third-party testing organizations that hold supplements to rigorous standards:

NSF International Certification: Tests for contaminants, verifies label claims, and ensures good manufacturing practices. This is the gold standard, the same organization that certifies Olympic athlete supplements.

USP Verified: United States Pharmacopeia verification ensures purity, potency, and quality. If you see this seal, you know exactly what you’re getting.

ConsumerLab.com: Independent testing organization that actually buys products off the shelf and tests them. They’ve found that nearly 30% of supplements don’t contain what they claim.

Red flags to avoid:

• Proprietary blends (hiding doses behind marketing terms)
• “Pixie dusting” (including trendy ingredients at useless doses)
• Unrealistic claims (“lose 30 pounds in 30 days!”)
• No third-party testing
• Manufactured in facilities that aren’t GMP-certified

The price difference between quality supplements and garbage is often surprisingly small, maybe $10-20 per month. But the difference in bioavailability and actual health impact? Massive.

The HSA/FSA Game Changer

This is where things get interesting. The IRS actually recognizes that vitamins and supplements can be medical expenses when they’re used to treat or prevent specific health conditions. IRS Publication 502 states that you can include in medical expenses “the cost of nutritional supplements, vitamins, herbal supplements, or natural medicines if recommended by a medical practitioner as treatment for a specific medical condition diagnosed by a physician.”

Think about what this means: that $150/month supplement routine? If you’re using supplements to address a medical condition (and honestly, who isn’t addressing something?), you can use pre-tax HSA/FSA dollars. At a 30% tax rate, that’s like getting an instant 30% discount on all your supplements.

The conditions that typically qualify include:

• Vitamin D deficiency (affects 42% of Americans)
• Iron deficiency anemia
• B12 deficiency
• Osteoporosis prevention
• High cholesterol management
• Digestive disorders
• Anxiety and depression
• Chronic fatigue
• Immune system support
• Athletic performance recovery

The key is getting a Letter of Medical Necessity (LMN) from a healthcare provider that connects your supplement use to a medical condition. This is where modern platforms shine, getting instant LMNs for qualifying purchases instead of scheduling doctor appointments just for paperwork.

How to Use Your HSA/FSA for Supplements

Here’s the step-by-step process for using your HSA/FSA funds on supplements:

Step 1: Confirm You Have a Qualifying Condition

This is broader than most people think. Deficiencies, prevention of conditions you’re at risk for, and management of existing conditions all qualify.

Step 2: Get a Letter of Medical Necessity

This document from a healthcare provider states that supplements are medically necessary for your condition. It should include:

• Your diagnosis or medical condition
• Specific supplements recommended
• Duration of treatment
• Provider’s signature and credentials

Step 3: Purchase Your Supplements

You can buy from any retailer: online, in-store, wherever. Keep your receipts.

Step 4: Submit for Reimbursement

If you didn’t use your HSA/FSA card directly, submit your receipt and LMN to your plan administrator for reimbursement.

The traditional way involves multiple doctor visits and paperwork hassles. The modern way? Crates Health handles the LMN process instantly, letting you use your HSA/FSA card like any other payment method.

Medical Conditions and Supplement Support

Here’s what the research shows about specific conditions where supplementation has strong support. This isn’t medical advice, it’s a summary of published research:

Depression and Anxiety

Meta-analyses have shown that omega-3 fatty acids, vitamin D, B-complex vitamins, and magnesium can support mental health. The effect sizes aren’t massive, but they’re real and clinically significant, especially when combined with other treatments.

Cardiovascular Health

CoQ10 for statin users isn’t just recommended, it’s almost mandatory given how statins deplete CoQ10 levels. Research shows omega-3s can reduce triglycerides by 20-30%, and vitamin K2 helps prevent arterial calcification.

Metabolic Health and Diabetes

Chromium, alpha-lipoic acid, and magnesium have all shown benefits for blood sugar control. A major review found that vitamin D supplementation improved insulin sensitivity in people with diabetes.

Immune Function

Beyond the obvious vitamin C and zinc, vitamin D plays a massive role in immune regulation. Studies during COVID showed that people with adequate vitamin D levels had significantly better outcomes.

Athletic Performance and Recovery

Creatine isn’t just for bros. It’s one of the most studied supplements ever, with benefits for power, strength, and even cognitive function. BCAAs, beta-alanine, and citrulline all have solid research for performance and recovery.

Cognitive Function

Lion’s mane mushroom, omega-3s (especially DHA), and phosphatidylserine all show promise for cognitive support. Research on older adults shows B-vitamin supplementation can slow cognitive decline.

Building Your HSA-Eligible Stack

There are thousands of vitamins and supplements across hundreds of brands that are HSA/FSA eligible. From basic vitamins to specialized nootropics, from protein powders to adaptogenic herbs, the range of eligible products is massive. Here are some examples of the best supplements to consider that are HSA/FSA eligible:

The Foundation Stack (Everyone Should Consider)

Supplement	HSA Eligible	Common Conditions	Recommended Dose
Vitamin D3 + K2	✓ Yes	Deficiency, Depression, Immune Support, Bone Health	2000-5000 IU daily
Magnesium Glycinate	✓ Yes	Anxiety, Sleep Issues, Muscle Cramps, Migraines	200-400mg before bed
Omega-3s (EPA/DHA)	✓ Yes	Heart Health, Inflammation, Depression, Joint Pain	1-2g daily
Creatine Monohydrate	✓ Yes	Athletic Performance, Muscle Recovery, Brain Health	5g daily
Multivitamin	✓ Yes	Nutritional Deficiencies, General Health	Follow label
Probiotic	✓ Yes	Digestive Issues, IBS, Immune Support	10-50 billion CFUs

The Performance Stack (Active Individuals)

Supplement	HSA Eligible	Common Conditions	Recommended Dose
Protein Powder	✓ Yes	Muscle Recovery, Weight Management, Nutritional Support	20-40g post-workout
Electrolytes	✓ Yes	Dehydration, Athletic Performance, Cramping	As needed
Vitamin C	✓ Yes	Immune Support, Recovery, Antioxidant Protection	500-1000mg daily
Turmeric/Curcumin	✓ Yes	Inflammation, Joint Pain, Recovery	500-1000mg daily
Beta-Alanine	✓ Yes	Muscular Endurance, Athletic Performance	3-5g daily

The Longevity Stack (Long-term Health)

Supplement	HSA Eligible	Common Conditions	Recommended Dose
NAD+ Precursors (NMN/NR)	✓ Yes	Aging, Cellular Health, Energy Production	250-500mg daily
Resveratrol	✓ Yes	Heart Health, Anti-aging, Metabolic Health	150-500mg daily
CoQ10	✓ Yes	Statin Use, Heart Health, Mitochondrial Support	100-200mg daily
Collagen Peptides	✓ Yes	Joint Health, Skin Health, Gut Health	10-20g daily
Ashwagandha	✓ Yes	Stress, Anxiety, Cortisol Management	300-600mg daily

The Cognitive Stack (Mental Performance)

Supplement	HSA Eligible	Common Conditions	Recommended Dose
Lion’s Mane	✓ Yes	Cognitive Decline, Focus, Memory	1000-3000mg daily
L-Theanine	✓ Yes	Anxiety, Focus, Sleep Quality	100-200mg daily
Bacopa Monnieri	✓ Yes	Memory, Learning, Cognitive Function	300-600mg daily
Phosphatidylserine	✓ Yes	Memory, ADHD, Cognitive Decline	100-300mg daily
B-Complex	✓ Yes	Energy, Depression, Brain Fog	Follow label

Remember: more isn’t always better. Start with the foundation, add based on your specific needs, and give each addition 4-6 weeks to assess impact.

The Bottom Line

Here’s the truth: we live in a world where optimal nutrition from food alone is nearly impossible. Between soil depletion, modern stress, and increased toxin exposure, strategic supplementation isn’t just for biohackers. It’s becoming basic health maintenance.

The fact that vitamins and supplements can be HSA/FSA eligible when medically necessary is a game-changer that most people don’t know about. You’re already setting aside pre-tax money for health expenses. Why not use it for preventive health rather than just sick care?

Quality matters immensely in supplements. The difference between pharmaceutical-grade nutrients and gas station vitamins isn’t just marketing. It’s measurable in bioavailability and health outcomes. Look for third-party testing, avoid proprietary blends, and remember that the most expensive supplement is the one that doesn’t work.

The supplement industry might be the Wild West, but with the right knowledge and quality standards, you can build a stack that legitimately improves your health. And if you’re smart about it, your HSA/FSA can foot the bill.

---